Homicide Law in Comparative Perspective (Criminal Law by Jeremy Horder

By Jeremy Horder

A couple of jurisdictions world-wide have replaced or are contemplating altering their murder legislation. very important alterations have now been advised for England and Wales, and those adjustments are a major concentration during this e-book, which brings jointly best specialists from jurisdictions around the globe - England, Wales, the U.S., Canada, France, Germany, Scotland, Australia, Singapore, and Malaysia - to check key points of the legislations of murder. Key components comprise the constitution of the legislations of murder and the which means of fault parts. for instance, the definition of homicide, or its identical, is particularly various in France and Germany in comparison to the definition utilized in England and Wales. French legislations, just like the legislations in a couple of US states, ties the definition of homicide to the presence or absence of premeditation, in contrast to the legislations in England and Wales. not like so much different jurisdictions, German legislations makes the killer's cause, akin to a sadistic sexual reason, proper as to whether or no longer she or he dedicated the worst form of murder. England and Wales are in a minority of English-speaking jurisdictions in that those international locations don't hire the concept that of 'wicked' recklessness, or of maximum indifference, as a fault aspect in murder. realizing those frequently refined adjustments among the techniques of alternative jurisdictions to the definition of murder is a vital element of the legislation reform method, and of felony research and scholarship in felony legislation. each jurisdiction attempts to profit from the adventure of others. murder legislation in Comparative standpoint - edited by means of one of many UK's major legislation specialists - contributes to that strategy and offers a full of life and informative source for students and scholars.

Show description

Read Online or Download Homicide Law in Comparative Perspective (Criminal Law Library) PDF

Similar comparative books

Judicial Independence in China: Lessons for Global Rule of Law Promotion

This quantity demanding situations the normal knowledge approximately judicial independence in China and its courting to monetary progress, rule of legislations, human rights safeguard, and democracy. the amount adopts an interdisciplinary strategy that areas China's judicial reforms and the fight to augment the professionalism, authority, and independence of the judiciary inside a broader comparative and developmental framework.

Lexico-Phonological Comparative Analysis of Selected Dialects of the Meru-Tharaka Group (Schriften zur Afrikanistik / Research in African Studies)

This learn is an research into the comparative phonology and lexicon of six barely-known Bantu types spoken in Kenya. those kinds (Imenti, Igoji, Tharaka, Mwimbi, Muthambi and Chuka) belong to the so-called Meru staff. The learn develops a brand new category of those six dialects. consequently, a dialectological strategy is used, including the research of wordlists and lists of brief words elicited within the box.

Extra resources for Homicide Law in Comparative Perspective (Criminal Law Library)

Sample text

V goes to hospital, but his knee becomes infected and he dies. If the provocation was not such as might move a reasonable person to do as D did, D can be convicted of murder if his intention was to inflict an injury with the bat that the jury judges to be serious. It is murder even if in the heat of the moment D had no idea that his action would lead to V’s death. In such a case, therefore, D will receive the mandatory life penalty. 18 If he is a man in his 30s, D therefore stands to spend eight to ten years in custody, but perhaps another 30 to 40 years out on licence.

22 18 Both of these are expressed to be mitigation factors in murder cases under the Criminal Justice Act 2003, s 269 and sch 21. ,(London, 2005) App E. 20 M Wasik, ‘Sentencing in Homicide’ in A Ashworth and B Mitchell (eds), Rethinking English Homicide Law (Oxford, 2000) at 192. 21 The three-tier structure relates to general offences of homicide but, for the sake of completeness, it ought to be added that there is a notional fourth tier. This is comprised of specific homicide offences regarded as in principle less serious than manslaughter, such as causing death by dangerous driving, infanticide or causing the non-accidental death of a child or vulnerable adult.

The probability of success may influence a would-be killer’s decision to try to kill; but it plays no role in determining liability consequent upon that decision, once made. The fact that killing is the reason why the would-be killer acts sidelines the degree of chance of his or her succeeding as a relevant moral and legal factor (most obviously, in the case where the wouldkiller succeeds in killing, but to a considerable extent in the case of an attempt as well). A different approach may be taken to mental states other than intention, such as foresight or belief that a prohibited outcome (say, an unlawful killing) will or may occur if a particular action is performed.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.83 of 5 – based on 39 votes